Dining Guide

Vindy.com Dining Guide - Serving the Mahoning Valley, Youngstown, Warren and surrounding areas
New Search  •  Get Listed

Rotelli Pizza & Pasta

Rotelli Pizza & Pasta

Rotelli Pizza & Pasta

Rotelli Pizza & Pasta
Cuisine: American, Italian

Location Information & Hours 5553 Mahoning Avenue
Youngstown, OH 44515


Phone: 330-270-8349

Mon - Thu: 11:30 AM - 10 PM
Fri & Sat: 11:30 AM to 11 PM
Sun: 11:30 AM - 10 PM

Detailed Description Pizza, Pasta, Perfect! That's how customers describe our menu. Menu items are freshly prepared, from pizza dough and toppings to pasta, sauces and main dishes. It's perfect because our wide varieties of flavorful dishes are made to taste great and please the palettes of everyone in your party. Rotelli's "World Famous Lunch" is a "Three Course" customer favorite featuring your choice of a cup of soup or salad, a slice of our amazing pizza and half of a sandwich..... A big lunch served hot and fast at a small price!!! Our lunch or early dinner customers also find our Calzones, Stromboli and Subs irresistible.

At anytime of the day we offer family pizza's made to order. And for those who want to break away from the traditional, we offer a variety of delicious gourmet pies. Our Tuesday night pizza special is a standing appointment for many of our regular customers, as we offer our delicious, hand-tossed 16" Cheese Pizza for under .00 at most locations.

For dinner, our appetizer menu is a great way to get started with items such as Bruchetta Italiana, Crispy Calamari and Mussels Marinara. For salad lovers, we offer an array of fresh-to-order and tossed choices including a Cobb, Gorgonzola and our customer favorite Malibu Chopped salad. For customers craving real, flavorful Italian dishes, we offer a selection of savory soups, gourmet pastas, chicken, veal and seafood entrees. They can complement dinner with beer or a glass of wine. And, if they have room left, we highly recommend they try one of our decadent desserts.

Average Rating
3.2 / 5
of 12 ratings

Add Rating
Comments (12)

Rating: 5 stars Author: 1 Posted: 2017-03-29 09:44:59

Rating: 4 stars Author: 1 Posted: 2017-03-29 09:44:59

Rating: 3 stars Author: 1 Posted: 2017-03-29 09:44:59

Rating: 2 stars Author: 1 Posted: 2017-03-29 09:44:59

Rating: 1 stars Author: 1 Posted: 2017-03-29 09:44:59

Rating: 1 stars Author: Bill Posted: 2012-03-17 14:31:24
Um... closed. Last year.

Rating: 1 stars Author: Jim Posted: 2010-08-20 16:37:20
pizza joint with no pizza!
Service was horrible. Twenty minutes after ordering we were told that they are out of pizza. What? Ordered something else and waited forever. First and last time for me. Good luck.

Rating: 4 stars Author: KB Posted: 2008-03-26 19:04:44
Rotelli's great meal great value. They have basic American Italian dishes, but if you can't pronounce the name that's the one to try.

Rating: 4 stars Author: Mark Posted: 2007-12-21 16:15:05
Great food
The food at the Liberty location has been consistantly excellent. I had a chicken caesar salad at Springfield Grille yesterday that wasn't in the same ballpark as Rotelli's. We go here often and are very happy with the food. I would give a 5 but service is a little slow at times.

Rating: 5 stars Author: cj Posted: 2007-10-06 23:09:48
I love the eggplant parm. Generous portions and great service. We go to the Boardman and the Austintown location.

Rating: 3 stars Author: ultimate85 Posted: 2007-08-29 07:32:09
On Tuesday's they have a good deal on pizza, but the wait time is extensive. I suppose if you're still driving, just keep driving "past" the Rotelli's and go down further Belmont Ave. to Jimmy's Italian Food. They have everything you can think of.

Rating: 5 stars Author: Jennifer Posted: 2006-07-19 15:27:48
Wonderful Food!
I absolutely love Rotelli's! The servers are always friendly and the food is the best!! Generous portions and great prices.

Top  •  Back to Results  •  New Search  •  Get Listed